Taser vs Stun Gun – Which is better for self- defense? If you are asking this question, you have a better understanding of your self-defense options than most people. taser vs stun gun
Lots of people think of the stun gun and the taser as the same thing. They are NOT the same. Taser vs Stun Gun, they are 2 different products. And the differences strongly impact their utility for self-defense.
Taser vs Stun Gun Comparison Chart
| STUN GUN | TASER | |
| Example Product | VIPERTEK  | Taser Pulse  |
| Range | Arm’s Length | 15-20 Feet |
| Effect on Attacker | Deterrence and Pain Compliance | Disable Muscular Function |
| Allows Total Control of Attacker | No. The electrical shock is painful, but it will not physically disable the attacker. | Yes. The electrical shock disrupts the normal muscular self-control of the attacker. |
| Cost | Low | High |
Stun Gun Basics
A stun gun stops an attacker in two ways:
- Deterrence
- Pain Compliance
Deterrence
A stun gun can prevent an attack before it happens. It is the loud crackling of the electrical current that is the most intimidating. Of course, this is for those situations where you can sense trouble coming or where there is a verbal argument that might escalate into violence against you. In those situations, brandishing the stun gun and giving a warning will deter some attackers. taser vs stun gun
Pain Compliance
The amount of voltage in a stun gun shock can be very high. It can cause a lot of pain, but it is not sufficient to disable an attacker completely. It will cause small reflexive retreats, but the attacker can choose to continue the assault. You can think of a stun gun shock like a sharp jab to the nose. It will hurt. It will cause some people to give up. But it is not a knockout punch.
Stun Gun Range
The most important thing to remember about stun guns is that they require direct contact. This means that you are in the danger zone. You must be within arm’s length to make a stun gun work. If you can touch the attacker, the attacker can tough you. taser vs stun gun
This is a reality and not necessarily a weakness. In fact, in a surprise attack where you are grabbed from behind, the design of the stun gun is the perfect tool.
So, when we consider the taser vs stun gun question, there is not a clear winner so far. taser vs stun gun
Taser Basics
A taser stops an attacker in two ways:
- Deterrence
- Disables the Attacker
Deterrence
A Taser has a very strong deterrence factor. Almost everyone has probably seen a video of police using a taser on suspects. A taser also looks more like a firearm and is more intimidating. Like with the stun gun, the deterrence factor is only useful in situations where you can detect the danger in advance. taser vs stun gun
Disabling the Attacker
A Taser can completely disrupt the normal muscular self-control of the attacker. A Taser can disable the attacker and give you total control.
Taser Range and Operation
A taser has a longer range than a stun gun by far. It shoots “darts” connected by long, thin wires to the main unit. The “darts” have barbs that grab the clothes of the attacker. The wires send a strong electrical shock to the attacker. The range of a Taser varies from 15-30 feet. The “dart” will stay attached to the attacker. The trigger on the Taser allows you to control the length and number of shocks to the attacker.
Yet again, when we consider the taser vs stun gun question, there is not a clear winner. For some people, the stun gun is the best way to protect yourself. For others, the taser is best.
Taser vs Stun Gun – Which One Should You Buy?
If…
- You are new to EDC and self-defense.
- You want a self-defense weapon that’s Simple and Affordable.
- You need stealth and concealment = able to hide in pocket or purse.
- You expect close range attacks.
- You want a non-lethal self-defense option.
- You want to avoid the hassle of a background check and govt. registration.
- You want a wide selection of sizes, shapes, colors, and prices.
Buy a Stun Gun.
If …
- You want to have complete control over an attacker.
- You want to keep distance from an attack.
- You can aim and hit a target with a weapon.
- You are willing to spend more money for protection.
- You are willing to carry larger heavier self-defense tools.
- You are a member of law enforcement or another defense organization.
Buy a Taser.
Table could not be displayed.
Taser vs Stun Gun – Stun Gun Pros and Cons
Stun Gun Advantages
Concealment
Stun guns are smaller, lighter, and come in a variety of designs. Today, many stun guns look and operate like other handy tools. There are stun guns that are also key chains, flashlights, and other daily items. Other stun guns have the appearance of common items like cell phones. Of course, these are only for stealth. They do not (yet) actually work as cell phones.
Functional
As mentioned above, many stun guns are built into daily use items. This makes them actually useful for non-emergency situation too.
Affordable
Quality stun guns cost between $15 and $30. So, you can splurge on a high end model without breaking the bank.
Portable
Stun guns are small and light. They fit into almost any pocket or purse.
Stun gun Disadvantages
Stun guns only work at close range. Of course, as mentioned above, this could be useful in some emergency situations. However, the general rule for self-defense is to keep a safe distance is possible.
Taser vs Stun Gun – Taser Pros and Cons
Taser Advantages
Total Control
A taser gives you complete control over the attacker. It overwhelms the attacker’s nervous system and muscles. They will not be able to move or even stand when you hit them with a taser. This ensures the highest level of safety for you.
Safe Operating Range
Tasers can be used at around 15 feet from the attacker. This distance could be the difference between life and death. If the attacker is much larger and stronger, you can avoid a close combat struggle that you would likely lose. Many Tasers also have probes that can be used if the attacker grabs you before you are aware of the danger. This is like the best of both worlds. You can fend off a surprise attack and get some distance. Then from a distance, you can disable your attacker completely.
Strong Deterrent
Everybody knows how powerful tasers are – including criminals. Most will back off at the sight of a real Taser. The gun like appearance and reputation are extremely intimidating. This will typically allow you to avoid the actual physical confrontation.
Taser Disadvantages
Cost
The main drawback is the high price. The value of a taser will depend on the amount of danger that you face. If you feel that your area is more prone to violent crime, a taser is probably worth the higher price. The expense of a taser is much less than the cost of an emergency room visits. It’s much less than the pain of serious injury. It’s worth it if it can save your life.
Luckily, both are excellent options for non-lethal self-defense. Whichever you choose, the key is learning how to use it well. A little bit of practice goes a long way.
If you want to see a taser in action in slow motion, watch this video.
